I ran across this bottle a couple of weeks ago. I'm pretty sure it's the standard Wheaton fare: on one side just below the eye it says "Doctor Fisch's Bitters" and below the other eye it says "Millville New Jersey". On the bottom, though very faint as through it's been rubbed down over the years, it says "Wheaton" and possibly "NJ" after it - it's hard to make out anything beyond Wheaton.
It does have a label on the front which says, in part, Grandma Wheaton's Re(letter missing)eipts with Tarragon Wine Vinegar just below it.
Anyway, I'm trying to determine the value of this bottle. I've seen blue Wheaton fish bottles selling online anywhere from $5 to $33.
I can't figure out how to add more than one picture, so I'm putting in a link to where they are:
Any help would be greatly appreciated.