Hi and thanks for posting such great photos.
Your bottle appears to be in excellent condition.
Note your bottle has a lip made for a crown top closure (still in use today on beer bottles) but is fitted incorrectly with a Lightning stopper. While possibly used that way at one time, it was not so originally.
Age-wise, if the mold seam runs to the very top of the lip, this is machine made and would date from, most likely, the 1920s or 30s. If the mold seam stops, then it is slightly older. The crown closure was patented in 1892.
Understand that at the time this bottle was in use, there were thousands of individual bottlers across the US. Many small towns had their own bottler, cities had many. The stopper on this bottle belongs to another bottler - Hutter was evidently a big concern since there are quite a few bottles bearing the name. See this link for a list of them. Did stoppers get mixed up when in use? Probably, but only for an age-appropriate bottle. Your bottle is several decades newer than the era of the Lightning stopper.
I would hesitate to label this bottle as rare. Just slide over to ebay.com and you can find a dozens of similar soda bottles. Things get interesting with "local" bottles when an individual business existed only for a short time and their wares are super hard to find. And...collectors of said local items need to care enough and compete for those bottles is essential to drive the value. Judging by the company name, I would suspect his was a pretty big outfit and the bottles are not hard to find. Consider the contrast between a bottle from New York City and one from a guy who ran a small shop in Arizona or Nevada at the time when there were only a few hundred people as potential customers.
I cannot specifically speak for this particular company's bottles but my gut reaction is this is a $10-15 item - a price I would put generally on all of its type.