For most bottles, we do not know where they were made - however, your bottle bears the mark of C & Co which was Cunninghams & Co of Pittsburg, PA. According to Bottle Makers and Their Marks (Toulouse) this firm was in business from 1879 to 1907.
I do find what appears to be a match at http://hutchbook.com/ - see entry OH0099
As for rarity, hard to say. Consider the many thousands of bottlers already gathered probably means your bottle is less common. As for demand, that is a question for Ohio soda bottle collectors..